An Open Letter to the PM of India from an ordinary citizen
Congratulations on becoming the PM of India, the largest democracy of the World. Before you get comfortable in your seat here is a wish list that we middle-class group people would love to share with you. We belong to 2.6% of the population who pay Income Tax. It is surprising that in a population of 1.3 billion; only 2.6% pay Income tax while the rest just enjoy the benefit.
Every time a government falls short on its finances, it catches the hapless middle class who primarily belong to the salaried class.The Salaried class is one which can always be kicked and squeezed to generate more taxes. Whenever the government has to generate additional funds, it looks forward to the middle class like surcharges. On the other hand, whenever any benefit has to be passed on to them like the savings from Oil prices a couple of years back, it fails to recognize them as a community.
Before I share the wish-list, I would like to make the PM of India understand what a middle-class family desires? It is Good education for their children, Owning a house, Job security, Good Health facilities at affordable prices and a Good Infrastructure facility. So if you want to make middle class happy just implement the following:
The Wish List of a Salaried Class to PM of India:
1.Reduce Income Tax –
The maximum slab for salaried class should not be more than 20%. Donald Trump has reduced the corporate tax rate for corporations from 35% to 21%. He has made the Corporate US happy. Can’t you make the middle class happy for once! I promise that all the savings will be redeployed in spending thus bringing positive sentiments in the market once again. So many governments have promised it in the past but in the end, they just tinker with either standard deduction or raise the minimum slab by a nominal amount.
2.One GST Slab –
It will bring more transparency in business and avoid generating black money. We still come across a whole lot of traders who are willing to accept cash and thus waiving off the GST. Clearly the present GST model of a trader claiming an input tax credit against his tax liability is not working 100%.
3.Housing and Housing loans –
Offer a subsidized rate of interest for middle class buying houses. After all, owning a house is the biggest dream of a middle-class family apart from their children’s education. PNB lost more than Rs 12000 crore to Nirav Modi. With the same money, PNB could have offered a subsidized housing loan to home buyers at 5-6%. They would have not only got their principal amount back but also the interest. A couple of % point less than the market interest rate wouldn’t have eroded their bottom line like today. Most of the government come out with schemes for Low- income group housing. But what about the middle class. We can buy houses on our own but at least make the public sector banks offer us a low interest than the market. The same public sector bank, after all, offers housing loans to their own staff at much below the market rate.
4.Control the real Inflation –
The official inflation rate may show a single digit of 3% (March 2019 inflation rate was 2.86%) but when you go out in the market you realize that the reality is different. Vegetable prices keep increasing every week. Milk and Milk product prices keep increasing every alternate month. Petrol it seems will never come below Rs 72/- a liter. The middle class could never rejoice the low oil prices 2 years back courtesy our Finance Minister.
5.Education –
Last but not the least focus on opening more educational institutes providing quality education. I remember in my school days in the 80’s and 90’s Kendriya Vidyalaya’s were a symbol of quality education. It was very difficult to get admission but over a period of time, they have lost that reputation. We need good schools for primary and secondary education, good colleges, good professional colleges. Every year more and more students are scoring 90% and above. Where will students who are scoring less than 90% will go? Private schools have mushroomed to cater to the growing demand for primary and secondary schooling but everybody can’t afford them. Private colleges have filled up the vacuum in higher education to an extent but then they compromise a lot on good faculty and quality researches
Yours truly,
A Middle Class citizen of India
Address – Still stays in India and not absconding
Proof of Citizenship – Aadhar, Pan Card, Passport, Driving License, Bank statement all attached
Proof of Honesty – Still pays his income tax and files returns, Pays Bank EMI’s on time.
If you have liked the story then click on the link below to read more such similar stories:
The new i-phone or the India phone of PM Narendra Modi
PM Modi – Apps you need to upgrade on your India-phone
Comments
19 Comments
You have touched all the points of a middle class. Govt should also consider education loans at a low interest rates so more and more people can avail this facility to educate their children.
Agree with you Arun.
The biggest one of them all – Trust Me and treat me with some respect
And help me trust others by creating an environment where trust is the default not suspicion.
I agree 100%. Trust factor has eroded in a big way in last few years. Any new government need to build that trust as well as start respecting people.
Our voice captured so well
Thanks Monica. Please keep reading my blog.
Interesting
Thanks Naveen. Keep reading my blog!
1. Income tax- at the present rates, a salaried employee getting around 7-9 Lakhs gross annual salary will not pay any tax assuming investment of 2 Lakhs , salary reimbursements etc. Most of middle class salaries employees in India are paid below 10 Lakhs a year .
2. GST – In a country like India, can you tax milk and Mercedes car at same rate ? No but at the same time 12% and 18% can be combined at 15%. More technology can certainly plug the leakage.
3. Loan – Public sector banks are also a business house and bottom line matters. Can they afford to give high interest on saving deposits and also loans at lesser than the cost of fund? Such largesses by governments in past have made them on the brink of closure. Why else few smaller public sector banks were merged with a bigger bank like BOB. At the same time, banks needs to see credit worthiness of the borrower and utilisation of funds for the purpose it is availed so that these do not turn NPA.
4. Education – This Is critical for a strong India. Quality of education in government as well as private institutions is poor. Teachers lack knowledge and skills resulting in poor students. New IIT , AIIMS , IIM do not get good professors since they are in B/C class cities but may be better salaries than metro cities can attract good talented teachers in these institutes .
Also fresh thinking on entire curriculum is also need of the hour.
Ranjeet the points you have stated are true. But this is a wish list! Yes, if Government agrees to all these wishes
they will lose a lot in terms of revenue. But then they have to start thinking in terms of new ways to generate revenue.
US Department of Justice penalises banks and big business houses in Billion dollars if they don’t follow the guidelines like doing business with a country which is on their banned list. Even Europe has started. We will also have to seriously look into it.
Ranjeet the points you have stated are true. But this is a wish list! Yes, if Government agrees to all these wishes
they will lose a lot in terms of revenue. But then they have to start thinking in terms of new ways to generate revenue.
US Department of Justice penalises banks and big business houses in Billion dollars if they don’t follow the guidelines like doing business with a country which is on their banned list. Even Europe has started. We will also have to seriously look into it.
Very well written Alok. Koi tho hamara sune !!
These are good suggestions which have been given by others also.in one or other way.
The govt is always seized with them in the balancing act of generating revenue for development. and giving relief to the people as has been detailed in the blog.
What is required is spritual development of people in terms of real aversion for corrupt practises , commitment to their duties,nationalism in keeping nation at top.Modi in his own way is doing the same by persuading the people to forego their subsidies ,by being harsh on corruption,by developing new work,-culture but he can expedite the process by drastically modifying the election practises leading to minimum expenses.We will see if he does it and how he does it It is a Herculean task for anybody but then,if at all there is anybody ,he is that man.Let us help him.
These are good suggestions which have been given by others also.in one or other way.
The govt is always seized with them in the balancing act of generating revenue for development. and giving relief to the people as has been detailed in the blog.
What is required is spritual development of people in terms of real aversion for corrupt practises , commitment to their duties,nationalism in keeping nation at top.Modi in his own way is doing the same by persuading the people to forego their subsidies ,by being harsh on corruption,by developing new work,-culture but he can expedite the process by drastically modifying the election practises leading to minimum expenses.We will see if he does it and how he does it It is a Herculean task for anybody but then,if at all there is anybody ,he is that man.Let us help him by beimg a bit less demanding ,to start with.
Thanks Mr Sinha for your views. My request is to anybody who comes as a new PM. In my opinion government will have to think of new ways to generate revenue.Look at US Department of Justice. They keep fining Banks in billion dollars if Banks have transacted with a banned country or a corporate house or for that matter Volkswagen which was fined heavily for cheating the pollution test standards. If government can find new ways to generate revenue, middle class can get some relief.
Thanks for your views. Appreciate it.
Well written sir.
Thanks Vinayak.
[…] An Open Letter to the PM of India from an ordinary citizen […]
Leave a Comment